The High Court in Mombasa ordered the Kenya Ports Authority (KPA) to pay Modern Holdings East Africa (MASAFI) the amount after it was found to have mishandled 21 containers of fruit juice and mineral water that consequently denied the importer any profits that were to come from the sale of the products.
The suit is one of the first successful claims from the political turmoil that paralysed business in Kenya and the larger East Africa region for nearly two months, and could open the door for other firms to lodge claims for lost business opportunities during the December 2007-February 2008 chaos.
The political turmoil brought businesses to a halt, culminating in huge losses that only ended with the signing of a power-sharing deal between former president Mwai Kibaki and ex-prime minister Raila Odinga. Sixteen firms from Uganda and Rwanda have separately sued the Kenyan government, seeking Sh4.7 billion for goods and property destroyed during the turmoil.
The petitioners claim that the government, through the police, failed to accord their trucks adequate security leading to loss of their property.
They have also faulted the government for opening the highway for use in clash-prone areas. Their trucks were attacked and destroyed along the Nakuru-Eldoret-Malaba and Nakuru-Busia highways. Intraspeed Logistics, Kampala City Traders Association, KATRACO Uganda and Mugenga Holdings were the owners of the 22 heavy duty trucks destroyed in the chaos. They have been joined by Dooba Enterprises, Willex Uganda, SEBCO Uganda, KPI Limited, Bunyonyi Safaris, Seven Hills Impex, Uganda Agricultural Tools, Board City, Bidco Uganda and businessmen Suleiman Bateganya, David Musana and Arthur Turyahikayo.
Justice Patrick Otieno has ordered that the KPA pays MASAFI $8,296,536 (Sh837,950,136) for lost profits, $819,544 (Sh90,850,914) for lost consignment and $71,000 (Sh7,171,000) for clearance and transport charges.
“I find that the KPA failed in its duty of care and find it liable for loss of Modern Holdings’ 15 containers. The inference I have drawn is that those goods were badly kept to make it difficult for location, identification and verification by Modern Holdings.”
KPA was also found negligent for not informing MASAFI that its consignment had been moved, and for not ensuring safe storage of the containers.
“I equally find that the failure by the KPA to serve upon Modern Holdings a notice of removal of cargo to Makupa was a glaring failure on its statutory duty under both Kenyan and East African Community statutes,” the judge ruled.
The KPA had in its defence denied that the political turmoil affected clearance of MASAFI’s consignment and its consequent transportation to Tanzania.
Author: Gesture Chidhanguro